Non-Scientists Talking Science, The Risk
Link to File
This article was written specifically for the Deep Time Journey Network by Michael Lemonick, a science writer for TIME magazine, a Senior Writer, Climate Central, and a lecturer at Princeton University. The Deep Time Journey Network knowingly rides the precarious knife edge between science and the humanities. We feel that this conversation is of great importance now as humans integrate the story of evolution into culture. Some resources on this site tell an objective science story. Others attempt to make a fusion between science and the humanities. In all cases, we call on Network members to make sure the resources are grounded in the most rigorous science. Secondly, we ask that creators be clear about where they’re coming from . . . an objective scientific telling . . . or a nuanced layered telling. This resource illustrates the precariousness, and the importance, of these distinctions. (Deep Time Journey Editors)
- Used by people who call the work: Cosmic Evolution, Epic of Evolution
- Learning Stages: Adult Education, Higher Education, Lifelong, Secondary 9 - 12
- Type: Article
- Keywords: science writing,
- Why I love this Resource: It's such a clear article about the importance of careful research and writing about science.
- File:https://dtnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Non-Scientists-Talking-Science-The-Risks.pdf
- Posted By: Jennifer Morgan
- Date Added: December 30, 2013
Scientists must also be careful when speaking on subjects not within their usually narrow range of expertise. While, in general, scientists have an easier time than non-scientists understanding fields of science outside their specialties because scientists have a familiarity with the basic concepts and procedures of science. Even so many aspects of the history of the Universe/Earth are complex enough that scientists outside their specialties must enter into discussions with an appropriate measure of humbleness.
Frankly, in some ways the risk is greater for the scientist. A non-scientist is easily forgiven small mistakes. A scientist often not so readily.